EDH Replacement Effect Question - MTGCombos.com

Home Submit A Combo Deck Builder Forums Picture Guess Help

You are not logged in [click to login] - [Join For Free!]

Forum Overview >> General Chat

Title: EDH Replacement Effect Question

Date Posted: Sun May/06/12 at 12:16am

Posts: 909
Joined: 13-Apr-11

Alright I have a question. When a general would be destroyed in EDH, it's movement to the General Zone is a replacement effect. Void Maw's "If another creature would die, exile it instead" is also a replacement effect (as I understand it). If it's an opponent's turn, and you destroy a general, wouldn't their replacement effect trigger first, so that Void Maw's replacement effect resolves first?

And if all that were true, and you could exile a general with Void Maw's ability, would the controller of the general be able to use the replacement effect again, so that the general moves to the General Zone instead of being exiled?

Sorry, if I explained that poorly, just trying to figure this out.

Date Posted: Sun May/06/12 at 1:13am

Posts: 2788
Joined: 13-Oct-09

If it's an opponent's turn, and you destroy a general, wouldn't their replacement effect trigger first, so that Void Maw's replacement effect resolves first?

As long as your the controller of void maw, then yes, maw would attempt to exile the general before it can be returned.

And if all that were true, and you could exile a general with Void Maw's ability, would the controller of the general be able to use the replacement effect again, so that the general moves to the General Zone instead of being exiled?

Hence my "attempt" comment above. However, to be technical you are not using the same replacement effect, as only 1 replacement can occur for each replaced event. The "into the graveyard" and "into exile" return to command zone are actually 2 seperate rules and therefore 2 seperate replacement effects

Forum Overview >> General Chat

©2006-2023 MTGCombos.com