Magic The Gathering Combos
Search Cards & Combos:

Home     Submit A Combo     Deck Builder     Forums     Picture Guess     Help

You are not logged in [click to login] - [Join For Free!]  





Forum Overview >> General Chat
Title: Melira, Sylvok Outcast...what the hell
Date Posted: Sun May/15/11 at 11:30am

StoneDevil
Posts: 5
Joined: 15-May-11

Hi everyone just joined to say my thoughts on this card. Sorry if i'm not doing this properly but it's my first time posting here
Any pointers on posting protocol are esteemed and encouraged.Please scorn as you see fit :)

I saw this card and i would like your opinion on it. Cause it seems to break whole game mechanics
Like...

Melira , Sylvok Outcast and ANYTHING with persist and say...goblin bombardment or altar of dementia or anything that sacs for anything
Doesn't her ability make persist return with no counters?
Date Posted: Sun May/15/11 at 11:47am

scottymandingo
Posts: 845
Joined: 13-Jul-09

I don't think so. Here's my reasoning: A creature with persist comes into play WITH the counters already on them. From what I understand of Melira is that creatures that are already out cannot have -1/-1 counters put on them. But, if they hit the battlefield with the counters already there, she'll have no effect. Does that make sense?

Oh, and welcome to the board. :)
Date Posted: Sun May/15/11 at 2:41pm

gericault5
Posts: 2788
Joined: 13-Oct-09

Sorry Scotty, but they come back without counters.

When a creature comes into play with a counter on it, it is considered to have the counter "placed" on it.  Here's the relevant rule

121.6. If a spell or ability refers to a counter being “placed” on a permanent, it means putting a counter on that permanent while it’s on the battlefield, or that permanent entering the battlefield with a counter on it as the result of a replacement effect

Melira will prevent the counter from being "placed" on the presisted creature.  so no counter

 
Date Posted: Sun May/15/11 at 3:36pm

StoneDevil
Posts: 5
Joined: 15-May-11

So what i say stands...
I believe it has been said before for other cards but now it's my turn
This is completely broken
Do these guys think the cards the cards they print?
Sorry if it feels like a rant.That's because it is

Cheers guys
Date Posted: Sun May/15/11 at 4:09pm

gericault5
Posts: 2788
Joined: 13-Oct-09

They think but overall it doesn't matter wizards is a business and the money is in standard so they only care about those interactions. It would cost to much to research every possibility a card can interact with
Besides melira is only a 2/2 so she is subject to every form of removal so she won't stay in play for that long
Date Posted: Sun May/15/11 at 5:02pm

W@W Podcaster
Posts: 445
Joined: 01-Jun-10

She can't die to a gut shot :P
Date Posted: Sun May/15/11 at 6:00pm

Jaalave
Posts: 1
Joined: 15-May-11

Just add Phyrexian Unlife and you're unstoppable.

And in response to the "easy to remove" problem, an Asceticism would work great, as it does give it troll shroud and a cheap regenerate cost. Throw in a few Withstand Death to get past Wrath Of God, and you should have a pretty solid deck.


[Edited by Jaalave on 15/May/11 at 6:02PM]
Date Posted: Sun May/15/11 at 6:54pm

scottymandingo
Posts: 845
Joined: 13-Jul-09

Sorry Scotty, but they come back without counters.


When a creature comes into play with a counter on it,
it is considered to have the counter "placed" on it.  Here's the
relevant rule


121.6.
If a spell or ability refers to a counter being “placed” on a
permanent, it means putting a counter on that permanent while it’s on
the battlefield, or that permanent entering the battlefield with a counter on it as the result of a replacement effect


Melira will prevent the counter from being "placed" on the presisted creature.  so no counter
-------
Yeah, I didn't look it up or anything. That's why I said "I don't think so." ;) I was just reading the cards. Good catch StoneDevil. I'm sure it will be abused to hell. :)



Forum Overview >> General Chat

©2006-2023 MTGCombos.com